Ask ten contractors and nine will tell you composite. We build both, so here’s the version that accounts for what you actually want rather than what’s easiest to sell.
The honest answer is that this isn’t a question about which material is better. It’s a question about what you want to do with your weekends, how long you plan to stay in the house, and whether the look of real wood matters to you. Those three answers settle it almost every time.
Composite vs. Wood: The Real Difference
Wood is a natural material that needs maintenance and rewards it. Composite is a manufactured material that needs almost none and can’t be restored if it’s damaged.
Everything else follows from that.
A cedar or pressure-treated deck in Massachusetts needs cleaning and resealing roughly every two to three years. Skip it and the boards gray, check and eventually splinter. Do it and the deck can look excellent for twenty years or more — and if a board gets gouged, you sand it out.
A composite deck needs soap and water. That’s the whole maintenance schedule. But a deep scratch in a capped composite board is permanent, because the protective shell is what you’ve damaged. You replace the board rather than repairing it.
Neither of those is a flaw. They’re just different relationships with the thing.
What New England actually does to a deck
This is where the comparison gets local, and where generic national advice stops being useful.
Freeze-thaw is the main event. Water gets into the material, freezes, expands, and works it apart. Repeat forty times a winter. Wood absorbs water by nature, which is why sealing it matters so much here — an unsealed wood deck in Massachusetts degrades noticeably faster than the same deck in a dry climate. Capped composite has a polymer shell specifically to keep water out of the board core, which is the single strongest argument for it in our climate.
Snow load is a structural question, not a surface one. It affects your framing, not your choice of board. Both materials sit on the same pressure-treated structure.
Salt air changes the answer. Within about five miles of the coast — Swampscott, Marblehead, Gloucester, Plum Island — salt is relentless on wood and on hardware. This is where we most often steer people toward capped PVC, which has no wood content at all for salt to work on. If you’re on the water and want wood, you can have it, but go in knowing the maintenance interval shortens.
Shade and damp matter more than people expect. A north-facing deck under trees stays wet. Wood in that position needs more attention; composite doesn’t care.
The twenty-year math
This is the part most comparisons skip, and it’s the part that actually decides it for many people.
Rough installed costs in Massachusetts for 2026, per square foot:
| Material | Installed |
| Pressure-treated | $30–45 |
| Cedar | $38–58 |
| Composite (mid) | $58–78 |
| Capped PVC | $72–98 |
On a 400 sq. ft. deck, pressure-treated starts around $14,000 and mid-range composite around $27,000. That’s a real gap, and it’s why wood still wins plenty of jobs.
But run it forward. Over twenty years a wood deck needs cleaning and resealing six or seven times. Whether you pay someone or do it yourself, that’s either a few thousand dollars in labour or roughly a dozen weekends of your life, plus materials. Pressure-treated also typically needs replacing sooner than composite’s warranty period.
Composite’s higher number is paid once. Wood’s lower number is paid repeatedly, in money or in time.
Where that lands depends entirely on how long you’re staying. Under five years, wood’s lower entry cost usually wins. Over fifteen, composite usually does. In between, it’s genuinely close, and the deciding factor is normally whether you mind the maintenance.
Run your own numbers in the deck cost calculator — it prices both.
When we recommend wood
You want real wood, and you know why. Some people want grain, scent, and the fact that it’s a natural material. That’s a legitimate reason and no synthetic board fully replicates it.
The deck is in full sun and used barefoot. Real wood runs noticeably cooler underfoot than composite or PVC in July. On a pool deck or a south-facing deck, this is a real comfort difference.
Budget is the binding constraint. A well-built pressure-treated deck is far better than no deck, and far better than a cheap composite deck on an underbuilt frame. If the money is tight, put it into the structure and choose wood on top.
You’re planning to upgrade later. This is an underused strategy. Build a properly engineered frame now with a pressure-treated surface, and resurface in composite in eight or ten years. If the structure is right, you keep it.
You actually enjoy the maintenance. Some people do. A weekend of sanding and sealing is not a burden to everyone.
When we recommend composite
You don’t want to think about it. This is the honest reason most people choose composite, and it’s a good one.
You’re staying long-term. The math turns in composite’s favour somewhere past the ten-to-fifteen year mark.
The deck is shaded, damp, or coastal. Conditions that are hard on wood are where capped composite and PVC genuinely outperform.
You have kids or go barefoot constantly. No splinters, ever, is worth more than it sounds.
You’re selling within a few years. A composite deck shows better at resale and removes a maintenance objection from a buyer’s mind.
The mistake that costs the most
Whichever surface you choose, the deck fails or lasts based on what’s underneath it.
Footings below the frost line. A properly flashed ledger connection where the deck meets the house. Correct joist spacing for the surface material — composite often needs tighter spacing than wood, and getting this wrong causes sagging between joists that no amount of good decking fixes.
We’re called to look at far more decks that failed structurally than decks that failed because someone picked the wrong board. A premium composite surface on a badly built frame is money wasted. A pressure-treated surface on a properly engineered frame will outlive it.

